PLANNING SUBCOMMITTEE

4 April 2001

9.30am to 4.20pm

PRESENT: Councillors Slatter (Chair), Blencowe, Cowell, Harrison, Hipkin, Nimmo-Smith, M Schofield, Smart, Smith.

Also Present: Councillor Johnson for application C/00/0092 as a Ward Councillor

FOR THE INFORMATION OF THE COUNCIL

01/j/31 MINUTES

The minutes of the meeting held on 7 February 2001 were confirmed as a correct record.

01/j/32 Apologies

There were no apologies for absence from members.

01/j/33 Declarations of Interest

Code of Conduct (non-financial) interests were declared as follows:

· Councillor Cowell in relation to application C/00/0050, Land at 42 Cheddars Lane, East Road, as he was a member of the Management Committee of the Cambridge Sea Cadets Unit.

· Councillors Hipkin and Schofield in relation to application C/00/0972, Cattle Market Site at 1-33 Cherry Hinton Road, as they were members of the Board of The Junction

01/j/34 Planning Applications

A summary of decisions on applications for planning consent is set out in the appendix to these minutes. Full details of the decisions, conditions of permissions and reasons for refusals may be inspected in the Environment and Planning Department.

Resolved that

1. Planning applications considered by the Subcommittee be determined as set out in appendix 1 to these minutes.

2. Conditions or grounds for refusal, which the subcommittee had delegated to the Director of Environment and Planning to draw up during the course of the meeting, following consultation with the Chair and Spokesperson, be as set out in appendix 2 to these minutes.

01/j/35 CHANGES TO THE SCHEME OF CHARGES FOR THE BUILDING CONTROL SERVICE

The report by the Director of Environment and Planning set out proposals for changes to the Scheme of Charges for the Building Control Service made under the Building (Local Authority Charges) Regulations 1998. These Regulations had been adopted by Environment Committee on 8 June 1998 and they enabled individual authorities to fix charges so long as the income derived was not greater than the cost of providing the service. Competition for the service was increasingly commercially orientated and the department needed to respond to demand for the service.

Resolved that in relation to the charges for the Building Control Services:

1. charges for Schedule 2 work (small buildings, extensions and alterations to dwellings) be increased by 5%.

2. A discount of up to 25% be agreed for building work associated with maintained schools where the estimated cost of work exceeds £100,000.

3. The current discount of 10% to 15% be continued for applications relating to Educational, Research and Development Buildings.

Appendix

PLANNING SUBCOMMITTEE

4 April 2001

No: C/01/0119

Site: Land to the rear of 17-29, Fulbourn Road, Cambridge

Proposal: Residential Development – Outline application.

Applicant: Kirkbowman Developments Ltd & Bofield Developments Ltd

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr R Wiles, a local resident, and Mr M Bowstead, for the applicant, spoke on this application.

APPROVED (by 7 votes to 2) subject to the satisfactory completion of a S106 agreement under the following heads of terms:

1. Provision of affordable housing in the event that more than 24 dwellings are provided on the application site.

2. Provision of an affordable housing contribution in lieu of on site provision in the event that more than 24 houses are provided on the application site and the remainder of the allocated site. The contribution to be calculated on the basis of the size of the application site and the document ‘The payment of the commuted sums in lieu of on-site affordable housing provision’, supplementary planning guidance adopted by the Council.

3. The ‘affordable housing contribution’ is due only if more than 24 dwellings are realised on the combined application site and the remainder of the allocated site, and if the remainder of the allocated site is developed within 10 years of the commencement of the development. The ‘affordable housing contribution’ to be payable only when 60% of the dwellings on this application site are complete.

4. Provision of open space and a commuted sum in lieu of the provision of open space on site in accordance with the Council’s standards.

5. no vehicular link is provided between Gladstone Way and Headington Drive.

and the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Reserved Matters details (C05)

3. Materials samples (C11)

4. Provision and retention of Car Parking (C21)

5. Cycle Parking (C22)

6. Full Survey (C30)

7. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

8. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

9. Boundary Treatment (implementation to be specified) (C37B)

10. Location of trees on and adjacent to development sites (outline permissions) (C50)

11. Proposed Trees (outline permissions) (C51)

12. Existing trees which are to be retained. (Full applications) (C52)

13. Tree protection (C55)

14. Construction Hours (C63)

15. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

And the following informative:

1. Considerate Contractors (AI05)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

No: C/01/0121

Site: Former Quarry & Norman Works Site, Coldhams Lane, Cambridge

Proposal: Reserved matters application for three general industrial (Class B2)/storage and distribution (Class B8) building (12 626sqm), and associated car, lorry and cycle parking, plus landscaping under outline planning permission C/00/0047/OP

Applicant: Whitecliffe Developments Ltd

DELEGATED AUTHORITY to approve the application be given to the Director of Environment and Planning subject to receipt of satisfactory information and clarification and amended plans in relation to the level of intrusion into the south facing slope of the Washmills pit and the following conditions:

1. Cycle Parking (C22)

2. Bin Provision

3. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

4. Details of Earthworks (C33)

5. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

6. Hard and Soft Landscape implementation (C35)

6. Boundary Treatment (implementation before use commences) (C37)

7. Floodlighting details (C38)

8. Use of the land between the buildings and the south facing slope to the north of the three industrial/warehouse units to be used as a service yard only in accordance with the approved plans and not for the parking of cars.

9. Confirmation of likely impact on television reception as a result of development.

And the following informatives:

1. Notwithstanding the details shown on the approved plans, this permission should be read in conjunction with all outstanding planning conditions attached to permission C/00/0047/OP, and the associated S106 agreement

2. The submitted landscaping plan, shall be read in conjunction with the submitted master plan (precise details to be agreed), and should be implemented concurrently, to ensure the comprehensive landscape scheme is implemented for the whole development, prior to the units being occupied

3. Prior to any development the applicant must implement all of the proposed remedial measures outlined in the ground works statement provided by SWP

4. Prior to the commencement of remedial works operational details of the remedial works; specifications of materials to be used; and details of health and safety arrangements, must be submitted to the planning authority by individual contractors for the remedial works

5. Prior to the commencement of the remedial works the developer will engage in an independent consultant to oversee the remedial works on behalf of the city Council (this is an auditing role with regular site visits and reports outlining the progress and successful completion of the specific works)

6. Unit B the central building within the industrial and warehouse development (to be occupied by Bookers) to be used as a wholesale cash and carry for wholesaling of goods to trade customers and ancillary preparation areas, offices and/or any use within Class B8.

No: C/01/0123

Site: Former Quarry & Norman Works Site, Coldhams Lane, Cambridge

Proposal: Reserved matters application for two car showroom buildings (1 943sqm) with ancillary offices and workshop facilities and associated car and cycle parking, plus landscaping under outline planning permission C/00/0047/OP

Applicant: Whitecliffe Developments Ltd

APPROVED subject to receipt of satisfactory amended plans and clarification of details and the following conditions:

1. Cycle parking (C22)

2. Bin provisions

3. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

4. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

5. Hard and Soft Landscape implementation (C35)

6. Boundary treatment, (implementation before use commences) (C37)

7. Floodlighting details (C38)

And the following informatives:

2. The provision of signs within the site and on the Coldhams Lane frontage will require the submission of an advertisement application

3. The submitted landscaping plan, shall be read in conjunction with the submitted master plan (precise details to be agreed), and should be implemented concurrently, to ensure the comprehensive landscape scheme is implemented for the whole development, prior to the units being occupied

4. Prior to any development the applicant must implement all of the proposed remedial measures outlined in the ground works statement provided by SWP

5. Prior to the commencement of remedial works operational details of the remedial works; specifications of materials to be used; and details of health and safety arrangements, must be submitted to the planning authority by individual contractors for the remedial works

6. Prior to the commencement of the remedial works the developer will engage in an independent consultant to oversee the remedial works on behalf of the city Council (this is an auditing role with regular site visits and reports outlining the progress and successful completion of the specific works)

No: C/01/0160

Site: Land to the rear of, 17-29, Fulbourn Road, Cambridge

Proposal: Residential Development with access from Gladstone Way (outline application)

Applicant: Hatter Developments Ltd

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr R Wiles, a local resident, spoke on this application.

APPROVED (by 8 votes to 2) subject to satisfactory completion of a S106 agreement under the following heads of terms:

1. Provision of affordable housing in the event that more than 24 dwellings are provided on the application site.

4. Provision of open space and a commuted sum in lieu of the provision of open space on site in accordance with the Council’s standards.

5. no vehicular link is provided between Gladstone Way and Headington Drive.

and to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Reserved Matters details (C05)

3. Materials samples (C11)

4. Specified parking, loading, unloading (C20A)

5. Cycle Parking (C22)

6. Full Survey (C30)

7. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

8. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

9. Boundary treatment, (implementation to be specified) (C37B)

10. Location of trees on and adjacent to development sites (outline permissions) (C50)

11. Proposed Trees (outline permissions) (C51)

12. Existing trees which are to be retained. (Full applications) (C52)

13. Tree protection (C55)

14. Construction Hours (C63)

15. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

And the following informative:

1. Considerate Contractors (AI05)

No: C/01/0972

Site: Former Cattle Market Site, 1-33 Cherry Hinton Road, Cambridge

Proposal: Amendment to development approved at former Cattle Market site (LPA ref: C/98/0355/FP) to provide additional multi-storey car parking spaces to replace the surface car parking spaces originally proposed but now to be “lost” to the extension to the Junction

Applicant: Turnstone Estates Ltd

APPROVED subject to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Materials samples (C05)

3. Surface water drainage

And the following informative:

1. The applicant should take regard of the information supplied by the Environment Agency

No: C/01/1187

Site: Land within curtilage of, 51 Derwent Close, Cambridge, CB1 4DY

Proposal: Erection of a four bedroomed detached house and detached garage

Applicant: Mrs M Williams

APPROVED subject to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Materials samples (C11)

3. Tree protection (C55)

No: C/01/0089

Site: 4 Laburnum Close, Cambridge, CB4 1BB

Proposal: Erection of a new dwelling

Applicant: Mr & Mrs Frostick

REFUSED (by 9 votes to 0) on the grounds set out below and the Director of Environment and Planning to write to the applicant referring to consent for provision of the annex and the comments of the Papworth Trust:

1. The proposed development would, by reason of the proximity of the access to the windows and curtilage of 4 Laburnum Close, result in an unacceptable level of noise and disturbance to the detriment of the amenity that the occupiers of this might reasonable expect to enjoy. The application is therefore contrary to the provisions of policy SP12/10 of the Cambridgeshire Structure Plan 1995, policies NE8 and HO5 of the Cambridge Local Plan 1996 and the principle of good neighbourliness contained in Planning Policy Guidance Note 1, 1997

2. The proposal, by reason of its height, scale, and proximity to the boundary with 4 Laburnum Close, would have an overpowering impact on this neighbouring property and fails to deal with the constraints of the site to the detriment of the amenity that the occupiers of this property might reasonably expect to enjoy. The application is therefore contrary to the provisions of policy SP12/10 of the Cambridgeshire Structure Plan 1995, policies BE2 and HO5 of the Cambridge Local Plan 1996 and the principle of neighbourliness contained in Planning Policy Guidance Note 1, 1997

No: C/00/1240

Site: Unit 5, Beehive Centre, Coldhams Lane, Cambridge

Proposal: Erection of extension to existing Unit 5

Applicant: BL Universal

APPROVED subject to signing of a 106 of the Town and country Planning Act 1990 to limit the range of goods sold and to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Noise Insulation (C62)

3. Construction Hours (C63)

4. Cycle Parking (C22)

No: C/00/1047

Site: 97 Glebe Road, Cambridge, CB1 4TE

Proposal: Erection of a new building to provide 10 flats following the demolition of the existing dwelling house

Applicant: Camstead Homes

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr T Moore, a local resident, and Mr P Kratz, for the applicant, spoke on this application.

APPROVED (by 8 votes to 2) subject to satisfactory completion of a S106 agreement to secure provision of a commuted sum of £15,561 and the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Materials samples (C11)

3. Sample Panel (C15)

4. Specified parking, loading, unloading (C20A)

5. Cycle Parking (C22)

6. Soft Landscape works details (C32)

7. Landscape management plan (C36)

8. Boundary Treatment (implementation before occupation) (C37A)

9. Tree protection (C55)

10. Construction Hours (C63)

11. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

12. Maximum height of building measured from the height of the adjacent public footpath in Glebe Road

And the following informative:

1. Considerate Contractors (AI05)

No: C/00/1064

Site: Northwold House, 92 Glebe Road, Cambridge, CB1 4TA

Proposal: Extension to provide improved school hall

Applicant: The Perse School

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr B Townsend, a local resident, and Mr Nix, for the applicant, spoke on this application.

APPROVED (by 6 votes to 4) subject to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Matching materials (extensions) (C13)

3. Construction Hours (C63)

4. Use of extension as a community facility for the school as a whole and not as a designated classroom

5. Sub-letting restrictions

6. Restriction of no of pupils on school roll

7. No amplified music to be played

And the following informative:

1. Considerate Contractors Scheme

No: C/01/0058

Site: 185-189, Hills Road, Cambridge, CB2 2RN

Proposal: Demolition of existing and erection of 4 storey building (with 3 storey rear wing) to provide 16no 2bedroom flats and 2no 1bedroom flats, together with 20no parking spaces including 2 disabled spaces and 40no cycle spaces

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr P Symonds, spoke on this application for the applicant.

Applicant: Berkeley Homes (Eastern) Ltd

REFUSED on the following grounds:

1. The proposal, by virtue of its mass and bulk, and prominence in the street scene which will be even more marked when trees on the frontage corner of Hartington Grove are lost, fails to recognise the constraints of the site or relate well to its surroundings, resulting in a detrimental impact on the adjacent properties and the local townscape. For these reasons the proposal is considered to be contrary Policies SP12/10, SP18/16 and SP18/19 of The Cambridge Local Plan (1996)

2. The proposed on-site parking layout, featuring 11 parking spaces in very close proximity to the common boundary with no. 183 Hills Road, would result in an unacceptable level of noise and general disturbance to that property through the movement of cars and associated emissions, which would materially detract from and be harmful to the amenity of the neighbouring occupier of no. 183. For that reason the proposal would be contrary to Policy E01 (b) of The Cambridge Local Plan (1996) and would fail to meet the tests of fairness and good neighbourliness referred to in paragraph 64 of Planning Policy Guidance Note 1-1 General Policy and Principles (1997)

3. The mass and height of the proposal’s east elevation, measuring 12m wide and 8.7m high, would, set where it is in relationship to Hartington Court, unreasonably dominate that adjacent property and create a sense of enclosure for the occupiers which would be detrimental to their living conditions. The siting of the building in this position demonstrates a failure to recognise Hartington Court as being a constraint on the site or proper recognition of the surroundings. For these reasons the proposal is seen as being contrary to Policy BE2 of the Cambridge Local Plan (1996) and failing to meet the yardsticks of fairness good neighbourliness suggested by paragraph 64 of the Planning Policy Guidance Note 1 General Policy and Principles (1997).

4. The application fails to demonstrate adequately the justification for the demolition of the existing buildings and is for that reason seen as being contrary to Policy SP1 of The Cambridgeshire Structure Plan (1995) and policy E)5 of the Cambridge Local Plan (1996) and advice in Planning Policy Guidance Note 3 housing (2000)

No: C/01/0063

Site: New development and extensions, 148-178 Wulfstan Way, Cambridge, CB1 4QJ

Proposal: Erection of single storey extensions to 16 existing bungalows and 4 new bungalows

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr B Fuller, a local resident, spoke on this application.

Applicant: Director of Community Services

APPROVED subject to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Materials samples (C11)

3. Provision and retention of Car Parking (C21)

4. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

5. Hard and Soft Landscape implementation (C35)

6. Boundary Treatment (implementation before occupation) (C37A)

7. Floodlighting details, buildings (C38A)

8. Tree Protection (C55)

9. Construction Hours (C63)

10. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

11. Permitted Development Restriction (extensions) (C80)

12. Permitted Development Exclusion (windows or dormers) (C81)

13. Cycle parking (numbers to be specified) (C22A)

14. Bin provisions

15. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

And the following informative:

1. Considerate Contractors (AI05)

No: C/01/0086

Site: Land to the rear of, 34 Cherry Hinton Road, Cambridge

Proposal: Erection of one 2 bedroom bungalow

Applicant: L Ruggiero

APPROVED subject to satisfactory completion of a S106 agreement to secure a commuted sum of £1,482 in lieu of public open space being provided on the applications site and the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Cycle parking (numbers to be specified) (C22A)

3. Noise Insulation (C62)

4. Permitted Development Restriction (extensions) (C80)

5. Permitted Development Exclusion (windows or dormers) (C81)

And the following informatives:

1. To satisfy the condition relating to noise insulation the applicant is advised to provide a suitable form of double-glazing, and alternative mechanical ventilation be provided to the gable end window to “bedroom 2”

2. Considerate Contractors (AI05)

No: C/01/0012

Site: Land to the rear of The Broadway, Mill Road, Cambridge, CB1 3AH

Proposal: Residential development, (number of houses unknown). (Outline Application)

Applicant: John Day

WITHDRAWN

No: C/00/1189

Site: 24 Brooklands Avenue, Cambridge, CB2 2BU

Proposal: External and internal alterations, extensions and partial demolition of existing listed building

Applicant: English Heritage

APPROVED (see report C/00/1190) subject to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Material samples – (C11)

3. Scale details (C14)

4. Prior to commencement of the development details of the method of obscuring the ground floor Easternmost window shall be submitted to and approved by the local planning authority in writing. The scheme shall be implemented in accordance with that agreed

5. Prior to the commencement of the development a sample of the proposed glass to be used for the reception building and details of the lettering shall be submitted to and approved by the local planning authority in writing. The scheme shall be implemented in accordance with that agreed

6. There shall be no external plant other than that shown on drawing 257/L/030 revE

7. Parking, loading, unloading as attached plan (20B)

8. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

9. Tree protection (C55)

10. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

11. Fume Filtration/Extraction (C60)

12. Construction Hours (C63)

No: C/00/1190

Site: 24 Brooklands Avenue, Cambridge, CB2 2BU

Proposal: External alterations and extensions to existing building

Applicant: English Heritage

APPROVED subject to satisfactory completion of a S106 agreement to secure a Travel for Work Plan and the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Material samples – (C11)

3. Scale details (C14)

6. There shall be no external plant other than that shown on drawing 257/L/030 revE

7. Parking, loading, unloading as attached plan (20B)

8. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

9. Tree protection (C55)

13. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

14. Fume Filtration/Extraction (C60)

15. Construction Hours (C63)

And the following informative:

1. The applicant is encouraged to take precautions against the potential for birds to fly into the glazed elements of the extension.

No: C/00/1216

Site: 154-156 Victoria Road, Cambridge, CB4 3DZ

Proposal: Demolition of existing retail unit. Erection of replacement building comprising, 1 ground floor retail unit (Class A1), 2 residential units (Class C3) and 45sqm office floor space (Class B1(a))

Applicant: Longventure Ltd

MINDED TO APPROVE subject to the satisfactory completion of a Section 106 Agreement to secure commuted parking payments and the rescission of permission C/97/0749/FP, and subject to the following conditions and informatives:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Matching materials (extensions) (C13)

3. Hard and Soft Landscape works (version to be customised) (C31A)

4. Required works completed within 12 months of occupation

5. Noise Insulation (C62)

6. Constructions Hours (C63)

7. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

8. Details of development (including demolition) must be approved in writing

9. Scheme for insulation of the bedsit and flat to reduce noise level be approved in writing

10. Delivery hours restriction

11. Bin provisions

12. Archaeology (C85A)

And the following informatives:

1. s.106 obligation (AI04)

2. The applicant is reminded of the disabled access requirements for the shop and asked to consider widening the entrance

3. Considerate Contractors (AI05)

4. The applicant is advised to contact the City Council’s Private Sector Housing Service for advice concerning fire precaution and amenity provision

5. Mechanical ventilation to the internal bathrooms will need to be provided

No: C/01/0138

Site: City Service Station, 155 Histon Road, Cambridge, CB4 3JD

Proposal: Installation of an ATM cash dispenser

Applicant: Esso Petroleum Co & Ltd

APPROVED subject to the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Construction Hours (C63)

No: C/00/0992

Site: Meadowcroft, Church Street, Cambridge, CB4 1DT

Proposal: Erection of 17 Apartments (following demolition of existing office building) with associated parking

Applicant: H & H Developments Ltd

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mr T Morgan, a local resident, and Mr D Hughes, for the applicant, spoke on this application.

APPROVED (by 6 votes to 4) subject to the completion of the Section 106 Agreement requiring

1. a commuted sum of £25,194

2. inclusion of 30% affordable housing if more than 8 units are proposed on the Chapel end of the site

3. incorporation of a 5 year maintenance plan for trees and landscaping

and the following conditions:

1. Standard Time – Full Permissions (C01)

2. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

3. Details of Earthworks (C33)

4. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

5. Hard and Soft Landscape implementation (C35)

6. Landscape management plan (C36)

7. Boundary Treatment (implementation before occupation) (C37A)

8. Floodlighting details, buildings (C38A)

9. Existing trees which are to be retained. (Full applications) (C52)

10. Details of planting implementation (Trees) (C53)

11. Tree protection (C55)

12. Protection of trees identified as T1 and T39

13. Protection of existing sycamores

14. Sample of gabion walls to be used must be submitted and approved

15. Details of front gates to be submitted

16. Cycle Parking (C22)

17. Details of refuse store to be submitted and approved

18. Details of foul and surface water drainage for site to be submitted and approved

19. Construction Hours (C63)

20. Details of Contractors operations (C64)

21. Details of relocation of the walnut tree (T35) to be submitted

22. Details of fenestration

And the following informative:

1. S.106 obligation (AI04)

2. Considerate Contractors Scheme

3. Investigation into incorporation of a lift into the building, the results to be reported to Chair and Spokesperson

4. Re-use of building materials from demolition of the existing house

No: C/01/0050

Site: Land at, 42 Cheddars Lane, Cambridge

Proposal: Outline application for erection of a new sea cadets training facility (Class D1).

Applicant: Cambridge Sea Cadet Unit

APPROVED subject to no new issues being raised before the end of the consultation period on the Conservation Area Notification and Advertisement subject to the following conditions:

1. Submission of reserved matters – time (C03)

2. Approval of the details of the design and external appearance of the building(s) and the landscaping of the site (hereinafter called “the reserved matters”) shall be obtained from the local planning authority in writing before any development is commenced

3. Materials samples (C11)

4. Specified parking, loading, unloading (C20A)

5. Cycle parking (numbers to be specified) (C22A)

6. Hard and Soft Landscape Works (C31)

7. Landscape works maintenance (C34)

8. Boundary Treatment (implementation before occupation) (C37A)

9. Floodlighting details (C38)

10. Construction Hours (C63)

11. Details of the arrangements of storage and disposal of waste associated with the end use shall be submitted in writing to and approved by the local planning authority

12. Scheme for ground contamination investigation, assessment and remediation to be submitted and agreed in writing

13. Prior agreement to the footprint of the proposed building, not to be in the form shown on drawings numbered TSG/35

14. Details of boundary treatment, landscaping and position of building

And the following informatives:

1. The current position of the first and second floor windows on the north elevation are not acceptable.

2. The eaves and ridges height of the building should not exceed those shown on drawing no TSB/35

No: C/01/0032

Site: Former Laundry Building, Laundry Lane

Proposal: Erection of 17 houses with access from Derwent Close following demolition of the existing building

Applicant: Pascuzzi Bothers

PSR: Under the Public Speaking Rights adopted by the Council at meetings of the Subcommittee, Mrs S Burch, a local resident, spoke on this application.

DEFERRED to extend the consultation period by a month.

No: C/98/0355/FP

Site: Former Cattle Market Site, junction of Hills Road and Cherry Hinton Road

Proposal: Variation of Eighth Schedule, Residents Parking, of the Cattlemarket Redevelopment S106 Agreement to allow an extension of time for the commencement of the undertaking of the first Parking Survey of the catchment area

Applicant: Turnstone Estates

APPROVED that paragraph 8.1 of the Eighth Schedule of the Planning Obligation Agreement be varied to read: “8.1.1: within 15 months of completion of this agreement to carry out the first Parking Survey of the catchment area.”

Agenda Item 6

No: C/99/0180/FP

Site: 27-28 Bridge Street

Proposal: Change of hours of opening permitted under permission previously granted; amend amount payable under S106 agreement based on reduced seating area; move location of extract duct and condenser units.

Applicant: Chez Gerard (change from previous applicant - ASK Central Plc)

APPROVED that the earlier decision of the Subcommittee of 23 February 1999 be amended as follows:

1. A S106 agreement to secure £22,200 in commuted parking payments.

2. Condition 6 to read: The premises to which this permission relates shall only be used for any trade or business purposes during the hours of 0800 to 2400 midnight Monday to Sunday, except for the external seating area which shall be closed and shall not be used after 2130 every day. For the avoidance of doubt, no members of the public or staff shall be present, or permitted to be present, within any part of the external seating area outside the hours of 0800 to 2130.

Agenda Item 7

No: TPO 2/2001

Site: SIMOCO land, St Andrews Road

Proposal: Consideration of an objection to the inclusion of one tree on re-served TPO 5/2000.

Applicant: SIMOCO

Agreed that the TPO 2/2001 be confirmed without modification.

Agenda Item 8

No: TPO 5/2001

Site: 420 Cherry Hinton Road

Proposal: Consideration of two objections to the protection of three trees in relation to Planning Application C/00/0329/FP.

Agreed: that TPO 5/2001 be confirmed.

Agenda Item 9

No: TPO 3/2001

Site: 7 Hedgerley Close

Proposal: Consideration of an objection to the confirmation of a service of an Emergency Tree Preservation Order relating to one tree.

Agreed: that the TPO 3/2001 be confirmed.

G:\Committee\MINUTES\2001\april\010404j (4 April 01).doc